TB5994

Bdu's? they are still available, cheaper than ever, we don't stop striving for the correct bikerscout parts because they are 30+years old do we? I don't want to reinvent the wheel, LFL did that when they made the film, we just have to look at the screen captures, compare them to the CRL, and see if a matches b... if not, change it... The schedule isn't for me fella, as you pointed out, the grandfather rights cover me too, like it or not, I just would like to see on screen to costume consistency for the future... It doesn't matter where people are in their builds... if they clear pre change, they fall into the old CRL, unless their GML over rules... if they won't make the CRL cross over, then dispensation can be granted do to circumstance... its only a costume club at the end of the day, not the Changing of the Guards at Buck Palace...

nothing takes more than 2 years to decide.... 3 months is ample time to show evidence, discuss and evaluate, based on the facts.

Nailed it in one Matt, nobody is asking anyone (else) to change an already cleared costume, its just the CRL needs addressing clearly, and based on images people can work towards.

http://images.wikia.com/starwars/images/d/d1/SwampTrooper-ROTS.jpg http://media.moddb.com/images/members/1/455/454717/Bak-hd.jpg http://images.wikia.com/starwars/images/3/38/41stelite.png] http://banthaskull.com/images/TLC_Photo_Archive/tlc_comic_red_clonetrooper_clonecommander_001.jpg http://stormaviksredbunker.com/images/kashyyyk5.jpg http://i121.photobucket.com/albums/o226/General_Fidelis/Kashyyyk%20REF/hist_scout06a.jpg

Got a link to the thread Jim?

cheers Carl

from my better half

Yep, £50 for a flightsuit with suede and elastics

Awesome work Rob! might even tempt me to dust off the scout!

trick is to cut small, test fit, if needed cut again... use a barrel sander on a dremel, keep going until you can fit your foot in and its comfortable to stand in, (don't forget your calf "expands" when you stand.... I forgot! ouch!) If it starts to look like your going to run out of lip, stop, expand, add a shim, and check again

Doubt it, as its not seen on screen....

then show us the images that back your crl...... unless you can do that, your point is null and void! at least if you do have a point, base it with fact! statements like "and thats a HUGE IF" clearly displays your lack of interest in any debate, which makes me chuckle, bsn hasnt changed for the better tbh, at least in the past, desisions were made or changed basedon fact and eevidence, not just mythical pictures nobody has seen.... somone give me a nudge when common senses kicks in, I just feel sorry for new members....

Everyone has a say fella, I guess that's the point, i'm just making the most noise at the moment

Changed a few bits already, raised the bund up, now sits at correct height, straps are now a lighter grey, they look black in the pic! Chafe pad is there, you just cant see it in the pic. I grab all my screen shots from google, plenty on there, including the one I posted. Your right, I'm in no rush to change my costume and it makes no odds to me if the CRL doesn't get changed, being accused of "flaunting the clearance procedure" on my Garrison forum I do not appreciate... I WAS the GML, I TRAINED the current GML, Christ I cleared him! The GML has final say, end of story, if he chooses not to agree with the CRL, costume reference library, based on evidence given to him by the person looking for clearance, then its his call, end of. The CRL chat has 2 blurry screen grabs in it in SIX pages... yet there is now a "set in stone" crl? Again, the Pinned WIP CRL only contains two members costumes as reference, one with this image? Apparently mc is acceptable, personally I don't agree, there is not one image of a green based rounded cammo used, but not my point, apparently, whitening ect make it more acceptable, (see earlier post) but the CRL shows unmodified multicam material used....? Misleading for a new or prospective member? The correct cammo? what's that then? this is the issue we had at the start? it doesn't exist, didn't then doesn't now, who defines what's "Close as possible" because it seems I don't agree, nor do others on what is tan or white, or what is a screen shot, and whats a pre production mythical image ony one person has access to... For some reason, the straps on the shins can be khaki OR white.... but the boots can not???? how does that work then? I do btw have the riding patch, but as the bund is low, the cod is hiding it! lol

Thank you. All I ask is that the two main issues be clarified with the images used to cement them in crl stone, be seen by all. There is a long list of "must be.." with no screen captured images, just a few shots of two staff members costumes...

the pouches being material is not in question, the pouches being of multicam material is... as they clearly are not. Your CRL states the cummerbund should be a two tone grey when seen on screen it is a single light base colour... rigid and imo incorrect, then you state the pouches can be either accurately painted to match the screen seen pouches... or multicam???? wtf?

basing a CRL on one single image, that apparently cant be shared is ludicrous. Why not base it on the 100's of individual screen captures that EVERYONE can see? I'm not asking you to change what you both have decided on, but to justify it with the images YOU have based it on....

So what your saying is you haven't gone for screen seen images... but from a single 3d model image only one person has seen, "but you took his word for it"..... Seriously??? can't see me rushing to change anything, based on one persons "word"....

can I please see the screen grabs of the cummerbund and the boots used to justify the crl? not that pre production snippet of the boot... screen grabs anyone have them? still not seen any...

agreed on the atacs and the oatmeal But seeing as you have to paint the entire costume, why not paint the pouches, rather than cut corners?

But if we strive for consistency, I bet I can give you 5x the ammount of pictures that prove that the boots are tan, not white, and the bund is one colour light grey... not two tone grey/dark grey... so the excuse of no access to hidef ect is tosh... you wrote the crl last year... not last decade multicam heavily weathered? really?

Right then... Been away from these forums for a fair while, seeing as I sold my Scout and Kashyyyk kit years ago, some might remember me, your all wearing ddpm undersuits because of me Just got my Kashyyyk cleared, not the one I won on this forum in an auction PHGfett ran years back, but another troopers second hand suit, previously cleared. Now i'm old school.... I see what I see, and use logic to explain why I do what I do, make what I make ect... the current CRL is confusing to me to say the least.... Boots, where in the film are they white? I've seen the snippet LFL pre production render, but to me, that makes as much sense as wanting to make an accurate Boba fett, then using McQuarrie artwork as reference... what you see in the film is a tan boot, with a tan sole, inches from white straps on the calf... This is what I see.... same in every screen grab... Whilst we have this pic up, why is the crotch "grey"? its tan in this and every shot I can find... Secondly, the bund... where is it two colour of grey, darker than the base colour of the armour???? now this has a shadow cast on it and its still not grey/dark grey... you can see the shadow line accross the pouch top right.... Pouches, multicam? thats a green base cammo, the Kashyyyk has a tan/sand base, also its a disruptive pattern, like Atacs, Multicam is rounded.... Now is it just me, or are you guys running with pics I cant see? lol and what is it with this forum, my "return" button doesnt work!

I'd like to hope we arent going to end up with a generic desig, if imperial crewmen can have thier own..... Clones (the comon ones) are TC, hopefully, if they do put us in a pot with the other spec ops style clones, Galactic Marines ect ect

Any news on the designation used for the Barc yet? I'm looking into having a name tag made up for my new helmet bag, not sure what to have on it though... This sort of thing, but instead of my SL, TK or TB5994, was wondering what "the powers that be" have come up with. Guessing it will be some sort of specialist clone tag.

you'd think, but I have four big ears and a pointy nose.....